While browsing FARK this morning, I came across this lovely lass:
Hmmm, redhead and leopard print. Hits some major buttons :)
So now, list must stand as such:
1. Alyson Hannigan
2. Neve Campbell
3. Alicia Witt
4. Kate Beckinsale
5. Charlize Theron
With Jeri Ryan as #1 alternate.